A backlink is a link from a page on another site to a page on yours. The same <a href> is an editor's citation on one page and an advert, a user's post, a template or scraper noise on the next, and only the citation is a publisher choosing your page for its readers.

Where to see a site's backlink history

Ahrefs, Majestic and Semrush keep a dated record of the links their crawlers find, for your site or any competitor's, and each keeps it for a different length of time.

Tool How far back What it keeps
Ahrefs Site Explorer 6 months on Lite, 2 years on Standard, 5 years on Advanced, unlimited on Enterprise New and lost links, the date each was first seen and why each was lost
Majestic The last 120 days in the Fresh Index; June 2006 to March 2024 in the Historic Index, on PRO plans Links found and lost, with the dates each was first indexed, last seen and lost; Backlink History charts new links for up to ten sites side by side
Semrush Backlink Analytics The links its crawler saw in the last 6 months New and lost links for a period you pick, with first seen and last seen dates
SE Ranking 7 days to 1 year Referring domains and backlinks gained and lost, by day, week or month
Moz Link Explorer The last 60 days Linking domains discovered and lost
Google Search Console No history: no lost links and no timeline The links Google has found to your own site, some since removed; its Latest links export lists the most recent by the date Google found them

Read the referring domains line before the backlinks line. One site that puts you in its footer adds thousands of backlinks and one referring domain, and a backlinks chart shows that as a surge.

Every date in that history is the crawler's. First seen is the day the tool found the link, and lost is the day its crawler came back and did not find it, which a server error, a moved page or a new noindex tag also produces. Open the linking page before you act on a lost link, and for the day a link went up or came down, open that page's dated copies in the Wayback Machine.

What the history explains

Links lost before a drop

Lost links explain a drop when three things line up: the pages that fell are the pages the links pointed at, the fall came after the links went, and the links came from pages that rank and are read in your field. Filter Search Console's Performance report to those pages and set the lost links' dates against their clicks: a fall that starts after the loss and stays on those pages is the links.

Then open each linking page. When the link is still there and points at an address of yours that now returns a 404, redirect that address to the page that does its job today, and the link reaches that page again. When an editor took it out in an update, ask for it back. A restored link counts again once Google recrawls the page it sits on.

A drop with nothing lost

When the history is flat and the pages fell anyway, the links stayed and Google changed its verdict. Ahrefs marks Google's updates on its traffic chart, so the date tells you which. A fall across the whole site on the day of a core update is Google judging the site again. A fall on the day of a link spam update, on a site that bought links, is those links neutralized: they stay on the pages and in every tool, the credit they passed is gone, and no disavow file returns it. What brings the pages back is a page Google judges the answer, and links from sites people read.

A burst of spam links

Hundreds of scraper, directory and foreign-language pages in a few weeks, the same anchor on each, did not cause a fall if you did not build them. Google devalues spam links on their spam signals instead of demoting the whole site for them, and most sites never need a disavow file. Leave them and open the Manual Actions report: only an action for unnatural links makes them your problem.

When you or an agency built them, paid posts or one sales phrase across unrelated sites, that is link spam. Ask for sponsored, nofollow or removal, starting with the checks below.

A competitor's gains before it moved up

Open the referring domains the competitor gained in the months before it passed you. Links from sites that rank and are read in your field, pointing at the page that climbed, are part of why it climbed, and those sites have shown they cite pages like it: they are the first sites to approach for yours. They are also the answer to expect when you ask an off-page SEO agency how many links your page needs.

When its gains are directories and paid posts, the links did not move it. Set its archived copy from before the climb against today's page and you will see what it added. Links from the same sites move your page only once your page answers the search as well.

How the history feeds the audit

The history names the links to audit first: the ones lost before a drop, the burst, and the referring domains your competitor gained. It also dates the question the audit turns on, why each link exists: a run of links that arrived in the same weeks with the same sales phrase was placed, whoever placed it. Each of those links then goes through the six checks this backlink audit guide sets out below, and ends in one action.

List the links

Export Search Console's Links report, free for your own site, and one crawler's list, and take every source URL from both. Google's backlink reporting is a sample: it groups pages by canonical URL, combines duplicate links, keeps links that have since been removed and does not say which carry nofollow. That finds the links; judging them takes the live page, so open the ones that matter.

Keep two columns apart, found by and live today, so a stale export row never stands in for a link that exists. Store the source URL, the final target URL, the visible anchor, the rendered rel values, the date you checked and the relationship behind the link.

The six checks that turn a link row into a decision

The rendered link

The source page carries a crawlable <a href> to the recorded target today. Google crawls links written as an <a> element with an href, so a button that runs a script and a URL in plain text go in rows of their own.

Keep it in the live set. Correct a broken or wrong target on your side, or ask the publisher to.

Why it exists

Find out whether the publisher chose the reference, or whether payment, an affiliate deal, a free product, a contract, an exchange or your own placement produced it.

Qualify every compensated link with sponsored or nofollow; a well-written advert is still paid for.

The passage and the page's purpose

Read whether the link helps a reader of that page do what the page is for. No vendor's topical score answers that.

Keep editorial references. An insertion unrelated to the page is a bad placement, whatever its domain metric.

The placement pattern

Find out whether one editorial choice or one template produced the link: a body citation, an author bio, a widget, a syndicated copy or sitewide navigation.

Report the relationship and the pages it touches. Eight hundred template instances are not eight hundred independent decisions.

The target and anchor

Record which page the link describes and in what words. No percentage makes an anchor safe, dangerous or valuable.

Check that the target still owns that subject, and read repeated anchor text as evidence of control.

Search Console status

Record whether Google issued a manual action and what it covers. Without one, read a fall in the history above before you touch a link.

Follow Google's fix when an action exists. Without one, remove or disavow a link only on evidence that you or someone you paid built it.

Read the rel attribute as the relationship

The rel attribute says why a link exists: sponsored for adverts and paid placements, ugc for comments and forum posts, and nofollow when neither applies and the publisher would rather Google did not associate its site with the page. An editorial citation carries none, and a link carries two when two apply.

Google reads all three as hints about which links to count, so a nofollow backlink is neither a defect nor a known fraction of a followed one: judge it by the visits and the readers it sends. Record the value from the rendered link, never the CMS checkbox, and ask for sponsored or nofollow on any placement you paid for, because the arrangement is yours whoever owns the HTML.

Use authority scores to order the review

Sort a long list by DR, DA or Authority Score to decide what to open first, and stop there. Each is a vendor's estimate from its own crawl and model, and none shows what Google knows about a page, how it weighs a link or whether a placement breaks its policies. “DR 70” is a fact about an Ahrefs metric, not a fact about Google's trust in the domain.

A dormant general-interest site that sells insertions keeps a high score from its past, and a page people read in your field, with a citation its editor chose, scores lower and counts for more. Opening the pages is what tells them apart.

End with an action

Every audited link ends in one of five actions:

  • Keep and monitor: the link is live, the relationship is legitimate and nothing needs fixing.
  • Correct: the citation is legitimate but goes through an avoidable redirect, reaches the wrong page, misdescribes the resource or is broken.
  • Qualify or remove: you control or paid for a placement whose link is not qualified. Use the rel value that names the relationship. Google's link spam policy names paid links, links required by a contract, automated links, optimized anchors in articles, guest posts and press releases placed on other sites, and links spread across the footers and templates of many sites.
  • Investigate: the pattern looks like a campaign or a network and you do not know who built it or on what terms. Name the missing fact.
  • No action: the row is stale, duplicated or scraper noise, and gives no reason to act.

“Toxic” is not an action. It packs the source, how the link was made, the policy question and what you do not know into one color; unpack them before you change anything.

Reserve disavow for documented risk

Most sites never need Google's disavow tool. Its bar has two parts, a considerable number of spammy, artificial or low-quality links and a manual action or the likelihood of one, and a wrong file asks Google to ignore links that were helping you. Check the Manual Actions report, find the links you or someone you hired built against the policy, get them removed or qualified, and disavow only what is left inside that case. The Google Disavow guide covers the decision and the file.

When the audit shows a citation gap instead of a cleanup job, the next question is link building: which page, which readers and which business result give a new link a reason to exist. The answer decides whether link work starts now or the page is fixed first.

Report what changed

A backlink audit report ends on what changed on the web: editorial references gained and live, the referral visits they sent, broken targets corrected, paid placements qualified, scheme links removed and the risks still open. A move in DR from 31 to 34 is none of those. Keep the discovery totals in an appendix, so a change in a vendor's index never passes for a change on the web.